Discussion : Should Guiding be only for Women and Girls?

Hello everybody! Welcome to or back to Guiding at Home. I want to introduce something different to this blog, mainly to get everyone thinking and talking. In my weekly Looking at Girlguiding I have mainly just been giving you guys information and putting my views across. If you do still have any questions about things in Girlguiding please leave a comment or email me at guidingathome@gmail.com . But I want you to be able to share your views, so on some Wednesday's I am going to make a discussion post with a topic. I'm going to share two sides of the argument to get you thinking then I want you to think about it and comment your side below.

So the discussion this week that I would like to start is:

Should Guiding be only for Women and Girls?

So as most of you know Girlguiding is an organisation that has been used to empower females and is only limited to people who identify as female, this does include trans people. This has worked for many years, the organisation gets to focus on the needs of young women and teach them to be strong against inequality. It's a safe place for girls to talk about female issues without maybe being uncomfortable if males were around. 

However it can be seen to be unfair to block out an entire gender from an organisation that they might enjoy. Males might love the sound of our meetings and what we stand for so shouldn't they be given the opportunity to join us? Girls and women are allowed in Scouting but we stop boys and men joining Guiding. The organisation is about empowering women but it is possible to do that with men in the organisation. In some ways Guiding can give the impression to young girls that men won't stand for equality and don't want to hear about their needs. We are also teaching young girls that they can't be open in front of men because they will feel awkward. It shouldn't be awkward, we should all be able to talk about our needs openly and not hide it away from the opposite gender. Guiding is suppose to be a safe place for girls to meet but by cutting out the male gender we put forward the impression that girls aren't safe around men and that's not equality.

I can see both sides of the argument so I would like to hear your opinion.

Thank you for reading and make sure you keep safe and keep on Guiding! 




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sewing On Badges

Image
Hello everybody! Welcome to or back to Guiding at Home. As a Guide I'm sure that you have earnt badges along the way but you never know what to do with them. You consider putting them on your blanket or uniform but you never have time or don't know how. Well now that we are in quarantine we have loads of time to spare so why not pick up a new skill of sewing and sew that pile of badges on? As I have mentioned the most common places to sew on badges are on a blanket or your uniform. If you aren't aware sewing badges on blankets is quite a common occurrence in Guiding because we like to have a place to display our badges and when we go on camp or gather around a campfire it's nice to have our blankets that show our achievements. They are also fun conversation starters, you can talk about the stories behind the badges and which ones are your favourite. You can use any blanket or you can get one on the Girlguiding shop. Sewing your badges on your uniform is also common and ...
Read more

Meaning Behind The Promise

Image
Hello everybody! Welcome to or back to Guiding at Home. In today's Looking at GirlGuiding I wanted to explore the meaning behind the Guiding Promise. Many of us have made our promise over the years and committed to GirlGuiding. But what does it actually mean? I'm going to go through and break up the lines so you can understand it better and maybe abide by it with more clarity. 'I promise that I will do my best' In GirlGuiding you aren't expected to be perfect and flawless so we don't want you to promise that. By promising to do your best means you will try even when you are faced with a challenge. You want to be the best version of yourself and we want that to. This part of the promise allows you to try new things and develop skills. 'To be true to myself' You are amazing and we want to see you being you at Guides. You are promising to be comfortable with yourself and enjoy the things you want. You stand up for your passions and sometimes have to realise...
Read more